Iran Hawks: Get Over Your Coup Allergy And Embrace Regime Change

by Ben Armbruster

Just a few months ago, Mark Dubowitz, CEO of the hawkish think tank Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, was trying to argue that he had nothing to do with Donald Trump’s decision to kill the Iran nuclear deal, and that instead, he actually wanted to save it.

Of course, anyone who’s been paying the least bit of attention to this issue over the years knows that’s complete nonsense. Check out this piece on LobeLog that explains in great detail that Dubowitz has, in reality, been gunning for the Joint Comprehensive Plan Of Action (JCPOA) since well before it was even agreed to, that he worked hard to dismantle it after implementation, and that his real goal is regime change in Tehran (or “coerced democratization,” as he put it in a memo to Trump last year). Dubowitz’s claim that he actually wanted to save the Iran deal—seemingly an attempt to absolve himself of any negative fallout from Trump’s decision to withdraw—was so egregious that even The New York Times took notice.

But now that Trump this week officially reimposed the first series of sanctions that were lifted as part of the agreement, Dubowitz, his FDD colleagues, and other Iran hawks could hardly contain their glee at the renewed opportunity for regime change and/or war.

FDD’s Reuel Marc Gerecht and Ray Takeyh of the Council on Foreign Relations climbed to the top of the heap with a 5,000+ word missive in Bill Kristol’s Weekly Standard calling for a CIA-assisted regime change effort in Iran. “Depending on what the mullahs do,” they write, “war may once more be on the horizon.”

Aside from the enormous complexities of pulling off such a regime change—and the extremely dangerous consequences that would result (none of which the authors address)—suggesting that the CIA launch another coup in Iran takes some real gall. After all, the CIA’s past involvement in fomenting a coup in Iran (or anywhere else for that matter) didn’t turn out so well for anyone.

Gerecht and Takeyh try to weasel their way out of this quandary by claiming that the CIA didn’t really have all that much to do with the coup in Iran in the 1950s. So, they argue, Americans should just get over their “coup allergy” because “it inhibits creativity.” (The CIA itself has admitted that it was behind the 1953 coup that overthrew Iran’s democratically elected prime minister. Gerecht and Takeyh acknowledge that the CIA launched the coup but claim that the agency called it off. That is also false.)

Dubowitz tweeted a link to Gerecht and Takeyh’s piece seeming to promote its call to arms. FDD’s twitter account piled on too and also promoted a quote (in a tweet which has since been deleted) from a staffer calling for occasional “kinetic action” (i.e. military strikes) in the Middle East to confront Iran.

Dubowitz himself appears to be working to punish any Europeans who want to uphold the JCPOA and continue to do business in Iran, an effort that experts say will further drive a wedge between the United States and Europe with potentially destructive consequences for the Atlantic alliance and the U.S.-led international banking system.

This renewed push toward war and regime change isn’t coming from obscure or unnoticed voices in Washington. However ill-advised and illogical its policy positions, FDD is well-funded and its staffers regularly appear in mainstream media and have influence on Capitol Hill and in the White House.

Meanwhile, Iran hawks in Congress appear energized too. On Monday, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) said on TV that he’s openly advocating for the overthrow of Iran’s government. And a handful of GOP senators just issued a stark warning to Europe against moves to preserve the JCPOA.

Combine all this with the fact that many of Donald Trump’s most senior aides, including his national security advisor and secretary of state, have for years been itching to confront Tehran, and it’s not just that war “may be” on the horizon, as Gerecht and Takeyh write, but that the United States is perhaps closer to a military conflict with Iran than ever before.

Ben Armbruster is the communications director for Win Without War and previously served as National Security Editor at ThinkProgress.

Guest Contributor

Articles by guest writers.



  1. The Iranian people have taken charge of their own destiny. It will be long and hard. No one cares about what the US internal politics is. We have seen how one US leader will use the Ayatollahs only to make themselves look good. You get the likes of Obama who approach the Ayatollahs only to annoy the Republicans, and then you get the likes of Trump try some other avenue to make himself look good to his audience. Iranians don’t care. We have our own destiny in our own hands. We have done it for thousands of years. Our culture is very old and very sophisticated. We will have change is a civil non-violent way, as that is sacrosanct. As I have always said, do not support the Ayatollahs, just because you do not like Trump. War with the Ayatollahs will be a gift to them. Help Iranians in Iran by preventing the sanctions the Ayatollahs are placing on Iranains, which are worse than any other sanctions. The people have been suffering from the Ayatollah sanctions for 39 years and have survived. Drought and hunger have challenged us and we have survived. Did any country come to help the people suffering 50 degree heat? Help us.


    Btw I am not affiliated to anyone. Read my blogspot called Iran News Blog. I apologise to Lobelog if what I say attracts derogatory comments from people who will make personal comments to me.

  2. Ali you can’t spout Western propaganda and expect Iranian people to take control of their own destiny. You and all the other Uncle Toms of your generation simultaneously talk about peace and independence, while practically BEGGING for foreign intervention. Me and like-minded Iranian-blooded people of my generation are sick of apologizing for Iran’s independence. For not granting America and Israel the kind of government they would like quickly enough. The sanctions have starved Iranians. They are young and poor and don’t have the luxury of pontificating about how great Iran will be once there are no Mullahs. A 15 year old boy died because he couldn’t get his hemophilia medication due to these sanctions. There is already blood on the pro-sanctions crowd hands. Have you no shame sir? You might not be affiliated with anybody other than yourself but this is still wrong-headed. You want to help Iran start a charity. FIGHT against the sanctions, not FOR them. Although I doubt your stubborn generation will listen. No they are content to play armchair revolutionary while the people of Iran starve because you’ve done such a good job demonizing the government that you forgot to take care of the people.

  3. At one time Trump had left a impression with his followers that he is going to push back on Zionists and the institutions they hold control over like media and Cinema! Well Trump haves in and caved in very badly! The position which FDD takes is not surprising and this trend will continue until the Americans are awakened to The nightmares caused by these useless hawks!

    @DOM, very good comments! The people like Ali are still dreaming of going back and take charge again after the Mullahs are fed to the Sharks of the Persian Gulf by the people at the expense of Iranian people’s lives! These people are the followers of the remaining Pahlavi individuals specifically the imbecile and incompetent Reza! All they can do is to bark with no biting just like a little dog that makes a lot of noise for nothing! Internally the people don’t give a sh&t about these people or their ideas!

  4. The more the likes of FDI, Gerecht, Rajavi or Tehrangelese Exiles pant about regime-change, the more secure the regime becomes.

  5. That is right Cyrus! The last time Mullahs had a cooperative control of power in Iran was during the Safavid Dynasty when they stayed in power for about 3 centuries!
    A lot of people including many of us are going to be disappointed because the Mullahs won’t disappear quickly!

Comments are closed.