by Mairav Zonszein
One year ago, former president Barack Obama delivered a speech on International Holocaust Remembrance Day in which he declared, “We are all Jews.” This is a far cry from the statement issued by the Trump Administration last week, which made no mention of Jews or anti-Semitism at all. White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus has since said that he does not regret the omission, but that “obviously” all of the Jewish people were “affected in the miserable genocide.” Apparently so obvious it does not warrant mention. White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer went on to call the widespread backlash from both Jewish groups and Democrats as “pathetic” and added that “the president went out of his way to recognize the Holocaust.”
It is hard to say whether the omission was a deliberate calculation that, as Virginia Senator Tim Kaine and others have already deemed, “soft-core Holocaust denial,” or simply an incredibly insensitive and disingenuous oversight. But what I can say is that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s silence on the matter is resounding. The Israeli leader who never misses an opportunity to invoke the Holocaust, anti-Semitism, or the threat of the elimination of the Jewish state has remained utterly silent on this matter.
This is the same prime minister who never missed an opportunity to criticize or outright undermine Obama. Yet in this case he seems to be going out of his way to avoid any criticism of Trump. When asked for comment, Netanyahu spokesperson David Keyes told me, “I don’t have anything on that.” Netanyahu’s silence is even more deafening considering that staunchly conservative, pro-Trump, pro-Israel hawkish groups like The Republican Jewish Coalition, and the Zionist Organization of America broke ranks and criticized the White House statement.
At Yad Vashem on International Holocaust Remembrance Day, Netanyahu implored: “Any person of conscience should speak out about resurgence of same attitude that decades ago openly said we are out to destroy Jewish people…. As prime minister of Israel I will not be silent, I have not been silent.” He only mentioned Europe and “the East.” When it comes to growing anti-Jewish rhetoric in the U.S., he has been deafeningly silent.
Where was he in the last few weeks as 48 Jewish institutions across the U.S. faced bomb threats? Why did he suddenly refrain from tweeting? Where was Netanyahu when Trump tweeted an anti-Semitic image of Clinton’s face superimposed on piles of money and a six-pointed Star of David? Where was Netanyahu when Trump essentially justified anti-Semitic attacks on journalist Julia Ioffe? And where has he been for the last year, with the upsurge in anti-Semitic hate crimes, the rise of the alt-right, unchecked neo-Nazi support for Trump, and his appointment of white supremacist Steve Bannon?
Netanyahu has already shown he has no problem commenting and imposing his views on Trump’s administration. Last weekend, he tweeted in support of Trump’s plan for a wall along the border with Mexico: “President Trump is right. I built a wall along Israel’s southern border. It stopped all illegal immigration. Great success. Great idea.”
Mexico’s Jewish community, which historically leans right, condemned Netanyahu’s comments and demanded an apology.
Netanyahu — who has branded himself more than any other Israeli prime minister in history as the representative and savior of the Jewish people — continues to be silent on the issues most important to them. Perhaps most disturbing is his decision to remain silent in the face of Trump’s executive order, signed on Holocaust Remembrance Day no less, banning entry into the U.S. to people from seven Muslim countries — a ban all too reminiscent of the ones Jews have faced, and a blow to all minorities in the country who started out as refugees and immigrants. The U.S. Holocaust Museum issued a statement condemning Trump’s ban and directly linking it to the situation in the 1930s and 40s. Jews across the U.S. have been protesting the ban by sharing stories of their grandparents who managed to flee persecution in Europe and reach the U.S. – as well as those who were turned away and perished. They have increasingly expressed that they feel unsafe and fearful under Trump, and Netanyahu is nowhere to be found.
Netanyahu’s silence on this issue speaks volumes about where his priorities lie. One likely answer is that he is focused solely on ensuring Trump’s support for continued settlement growth, disbanding the deal with Iran, the denial of Palestinian rights, and continued U.S. military aid – all at the expense of Jewish values.
It could be that Trump’s racist and exclusionary policies tacitly jive well with Netanyahu and Zionism’s fundamental vision that Israel is the only safe place for Jews in the world — the place they should and will eventually end up once the rest of the world spits them out. This demonstrates the dangerously smooth convergence between rising anti-Semitic white nationalism and the right-wing Zionism that Netanyahu is peddling. It exposes the fact that the Israeli leader isn’t interested in defending the rights of Jews as human beings, and that he is totally out of touch with the values of the majority of American Jews.
A much more appropriate statement from the self-proclaimed leader of the Jewish people would have been what was so eloquently stated last year by the former president with a Muslim middle name: “Because anti-Semitism is a distillation, an expression of an evil that runs through so much of human history, and if we do not answer that, we do not answer any other form of evil. When any Jew anywhere is targeted just for being Jewish, we all have to respond as Roddie Edmonds did — we are all Jews.”
Mairav Zonszein is an independent writer, translator and editor. Her publications include The Guardian, The New York Times, Salon, The Daily Beast, National Geographic, Al Jazeera America, and The Forward. Republished, with permission, from +972 Magazine.
“Netanyahu — who has branded himself more than any other Israeli prime minister in history as the representative and savior of the Jewish people — continues to be silent on the issues most important to them.”
Utter nonsense. The issues most important to the Jewish people are the survival and flourishing of the Jewish people. That means two things: protecting Jewish people in other countries and assuring a strong and prospering Jewish state of Israel. Letting more people who already hate Jews into the country is not a good idea.
I will take strong action in these regards over nice words about how awful the Holocaust was any day. In other words, Obama had nice words about the past and then took steps to hurt Israel in the today and future.
This author is more interested in condemning Israel for the plight of Palestinians than in the issues most important to Jews. I can only conclude the issues most important to the author are leftist ideals that have nothing to do with the welfare of the Jewish people.
That the author makes the miserably poor analogy between the plight of Muslims from seven countries on the no entry list and the Jews of Germany completely discredits the author. Germany for all its sins was a functioning and orderly state in the 1930s. It would have been very simple to vet the Jewish refugees. Not true with people in Syria or Somalia for example. The USA had relations with Germany in the 1930s. Not true with Syria or Somalia for example. Finally and most importantly, the German Jews were not affiliated with any terrorist organizations or members of a religion associated with violent Jihad or forced conversions while the Muslims are. That does not mean all Muslims in these countries are terrorists but a significant number are while no Jews in Germany were terrorists or the equivalent of Jihadi’s.
While more Jews should have been allowed into the USA, the more pressing point is they were not allowed into Palestine either due to the perfidy of the English, who have blood on their hands.
Strange times, these.
Now we have pro-Israel antisemites in the White House, and Netanyahu
pretends not to notice.
Poor Obama was in Nothin-ya-who’s pocket and BO gave Israel whatever they asked for and more including $3.8 billion per year! I believe PM is afraid of or uneasy about Trump’s unpredictability and he is kissing up to Trump! So the table is turned on Israel and it’s about time for someone to put them back in the box! It is unfortunate that that someone happened to be the so-called- president!
And what exactly did the Jewish terrorists in Palestine – the founding fathers of Israel – do to help their co-religionists trying to flee Europe? One thing they did was to bomb the SS Patria, anchored at Haifa, in November 1940, killing over 200 Jewish refugees who were on board her at the time.
And what exactly is a “pro Israel antisemite”?!?
That’s probably the most obviously Orwellian phrasing I have heard in a long time.
It’s no mystery why Netanyahu has been silent on the faux holocaust controversy.
The meaning of words sometimes depend on who says it. When friends of Israel and friends of Jews, like the current administration, makes a statement on the holocaust, without specifically mentioning Jews, the purpose isn’t malignant revisionism.
It’s rather because it’s so obvious that the holocaust is about the Jewish tragedy, that it goes without saying.
To put it in a way Marxists would understand it: Everybody knows who the victims of the “Nakhba” were. It’s superfluous to say “the Palestinian Nakhba”.
Comments are closed.