Rep. Sherman: Prosecute U.S. Citizens involved with Gaza Flotilla

On a press call hosted by a pro-Israel organization, Rep. Brad Sherman, Democrat of California, told reporters that he intends to seek the prosecution of any U.S. citizens who were aboard or involved with the Freedom Flotilla.

“The Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 [PDF] makes it absolutely illegal for any American to give food, money, school supplies, paper clips, concrete or weapons to Hamas or any of its officials,” Sherman said on the Israel Project call, conflating Hamas and Gaza’s civilian population. “And so I will be asking the Attorney General to prosecute any American involved in what was clearly an effort to give items of value to a terrorist organization.”

Sherman also said that he plans on working with the Department of Homeland Security to make sure that any non-U.S. citizen involved with or aboard the Flotilla are excluded from entering the U.S.

Hamas, considered a foreign terrorist organization by the U.S. State Department, won Palestinian parliamentary elections in 2006 and has held de facto rule over the Gaza Strip since it took the area by force in 2007 in anticipation of an impending U.S.-backed coup d’etat by the rival Fatah faction.

The Freedom Flotilla was organized by the Free Gaza Movement to break the Israeli blockade of Gaza — in place since Hamas’s takeover — and deliver tons of food aid, medical and school supplies and building materials to repair buildings damaged in the month-long Israeli assault of Gaza in Dec. 2008 and Jan. 2009. The Flotilla was raided by Israeli commandos in international waters during the early hours of Monday morning, leaving at least nine people, including one U.S. citizen, dead.

Though the nine were killed by the IDF, Sherman criticized the Obama administration for not directly blaming Hamas, using the logic that the militant movement brought the blockade on itself: “I think the U.S. could be better now about condemning Hamas as responsible for those nine deaths.”

The blockade and the land siege (by Israel and Egypt) have, by international consensus (leaving out Israel and its hard-line American allies) caused a humanitarian crisis among Gaza’s civilian population.

The Congressman, known as a pro-Israel stalwart who has, in the past, joined as the sole Democrat on Republican criticisms of Obama’s foreign policy toward Israel, denied that there was a “hunger crisis” or “humanitarian crisis” in the Gaza Strip. “The health circumstances in Gaza are better than they are in many American cities,” he added later.

Questions about the legality of the Israeli blockade and its enforcement in international waters were quickly dismissed by Sherman, who said that the U.S. had itself blockaded Germany in both World Wars, Japan in the Second, Cuba during the missile crisis, and, curiously, the Confederacy during the Civil War.

The irony of the last example was, I’m sure, lost on Sherman. It was in that war, of course, that another man named Sherman, a Union officer, led a scorched-Earth campaign against the blockaded Confederacy. There are similar examples from the recent Gaza War, which I’d bed Rep. Sherman also had no problem with. (And are we really reduced to using a conflict from 150 years ago to justify military actions of the IDF?)

While Israel alleges ties between IHH, a Turkish relief organization involved in the Flotilla, and terror groups, many credible doubts have been raised about that assertion (see LobeLog contributors Marsha Cohen and Max Blumenthal‘s pieces on the subject). Nonetheless, Sherman insisted the group has “clear terrorist ties.”

The California Congressman also blamed the media for the harsh criticisms of Israel since the incident on the Med (even from tiny Central American countries). Sherman employed what he called the “Kent State Rorschach Test” — referring to a generation of journalists who grew up in the Vietnam War-era and viewed Western governments critically because of incidents like the 1970 Kent State massacre.

“The liberal media is misled by that Kent State Rorschach Test that is a belief that those who are poorer, less technological, and more scruffy looking are right,” he said, alluding to skepticism of “Westerners, Europeans, and the U.S.”

All of Israel’s problems, said Sherman, are a distraction from Iran’s nuclear program, which he alleged is aimed at nuclear weapons. If Iran acquires those weapons, he said, the U.S. itself will be in danger: “You could smuggle one into the States in a bale of marijuana.”

“What really matters is the Iran nuclear program and we have a short amount of time to stop that program,” Sherman went on. “And our failure to take all the action to stop that program could force Israel to take an action far more controversial than what they’ve done this week.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Ali Gharib

Ali Gharib is a New York-based journalist on U.S. foreign policy with a focus on the Middle East and Central Asia. His work has appeared at Inter Press Service, where he was the Deputy Washington Bureau Chief; the Buffalo Beast; Huffington Post; Mondoweiss; Right Web; and Alternet. He holds a Master's degree in Philosophy and Public Policy from the London School of Economics and Political Science. A proud Iranian-American and fluent Farsi speaker, Ali was born in California and raised in D.C.



  1. America is now an israerli colony with all the necessary power in place to force and inforce any thing they want. They now have made most of the american politicvians of the highest order bow in fear of them and do immediately what they want whithout even asking. What a great nation this has become!!! What closely following of a Constitution that was great and now just a piece of insignificant paper. Horray politicians, make the israeli gain what they have said they would, control of the entire world. They said this, they said exactly what they were going to do, and now with the wonderful help of our heroic leading polkiticians, they have arrived. Thank you for making the world a safe place for our children.

  2. The Symington amendment to the Foreign Relations Act prohibits any military aid to nations which have nuclear programs that are not members of the NPT and CTBT; but this definition ALL military aid to Israel is illegal, but you don’t see the murder lovers in congress bringing up that one salient point…

  3. Dear “Representative” Sherman. It is illegal under the 1976 Symington Amendment to the 1961 Foreign Appropriations Act to give foreign aid to any nation that possesses and traffics in nuclear weapons technology that doe snot sign the NNPT and allow IAEA inspections of its facilities. This is also illegal under the Glenn Act.

    Documents published by the British Press prove that Israel not only has nuclear weapons but attempted to sell some to the Apartheid Regime in South Africa.

    That you are being quite selective in the laws you wish to enforce is obvious to all, as is your pro-Israel bias.

    No government can serve two masters, and a government that serves Israel cannot serve the American people. A friend to Israel is no friend of America.

    How dare you attack Americans on behalf of Israel! Please remember that this sort of behavior is what got Charles I into trouble.

  4. Dear Rep. Brad Sherman (dumbass-Calif): I support the aid to Gaza flotilla. I support the Free Gaza Movement. I condemn Israeli piracy, murder, and terrorism. The freak Israelis MURDERED an American citizen. Why would you not condemn the murder of an American citizen?
    Golly Brad, you sure are servile. So gee-whiz Brad, do you need my address and phone number? Cause I would be more than happy to forward that info along to you. Oh yeah, I think the world of Hizbullah too. Hamas is the LEGALLY elected government in Gaza and how is that a problem? Because Israel says so? Oh horses*@t! Remember how the U.N. “monitored” those Gaza elections after Israel pitched the histrionic fit about Palestinian elections? Oh yeah, they did too.
    So go ahead and prosecute me you treasonous flea-bag. Do it and never ever threaten me with a good time. FREE GAZA! END ISRAELI APARTHEID! Oh yeah and lastly there Brad buddy? Kiss my really white posterior. I’ll show it to you if’n you’d like. Ain’t see the light of day in a really long time and ergo, it’s really really white.
    Ditch the histrionics Brad and shut your yip. You do America and our Constitutional way of life a huge disservice by playing the lickspittle for Israel. Golly Brad, whom do you serve in ‘we the people’s’ House?
    don nash
    Layton, Utah

  5. Who is this guy?
    A poster boy for Hezbollah recruitment?

    If Hezbollah recruited openly world wide, they’d probably find two or three BILLION volunteers to battle the Devil and his minions, aka, Israel.

Comments are closed.