LobeLog on Facebook LobeLog on Facebook

Iran no image

Published on March 8th, 2013 | by Guest

1

For Iran and Pakistan, Energy Trumps Enmity

by Fatemeh Aman

via IPS News

Iran appears to be putting its immediate economic and strategic needs ahead of religious solidarity as it seeks to promote ties with neighbouring Pakistan.

Judging from a recent visit to Iran by Pakistani President Asef Ali Zardari, the two countries are more interested in improving their bilateral ties than in engaging in accusations over recent religious atrocities in Pakistan or resurrecting their support for rival factions in Afghanistan as international forces there depart.

Considering Iran’s strong pro-Shiite stance, one would have expected that the recent killing of over 100 Pakistani Shiites by a militant Salafi Sunni extremist group, Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, would have been one of the main topics discussed during Zardari’s two-day visit to Iran, which ended Feb. 28.

Instead, the issue was overshadowed by the so-called “Peace Pipeline” project, which aims to send Iranian natural gas to energy-poor Pakistan.

In the meeting between Zardari and Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the issue of religious unrest in Pakistan was discussed only briefly. Khamenei said he regretted the religious killings in Pakistan and called for bold actions to preserve “Pakistan’s national unity”.

The Iranian media blamed the killings on “Wahhabi terrorists, supported by the U.S. and Zionist regimes” rather than on the Pakistani government for failing to protect Shiites.

Iran’s lack of active support for Shiites in Pakistan could also be attributed to the fact that Pakistani Shiites are very diverse and some groups are not necessarily great fans of Iran’s model of theocratic rule.

The highlight of the Zardari-Khamenei meeting was a discussion of “Pakistan’s energy needs”. “In this region,” theayatollah stated, “Only the Islamic Republic of Iran possesses safe energy resources and we are prepared to provide Pakistan with its energy needs.”

Zardari was quoted as saying that “the attempt by the international and regional players to prevent strengthening relations between Iran and Pakistan is a failed attempt as the nations have learned to act against Islam’s enemies.”

At present, Turkey is the only major importer of Iran’s large gas resources, purchasing about 30 million cubic metres per day. That is just a small fraction of the 600 million cubic metres a day that Iran, whose gas resources are second only to Russia, produces.

Most of the production is consumed domestically since the country lacks the means to export the gas as liquid or to stockpile it. Work has begun on another pipeline from Iran to Iraq and Syria that was approved by the Iraqi cabinet last month but it is questionable how quickly that project can be completed, especially given the deteriorating security conditions in Syria.

Considering the impact of sanctions on Iran, the leadership seeks stronger ties with South Asia for two reasons.

First, to demonstrate to the Iranian people that more countries are resisting U.S. pressure. Second, Iran hopes that joint projects that involve the interest of neighbouring countries, some of them U.S. allies, could deter military strikes against this infrastructure.

At the same time, Pakistan is facing a growing energy crisis which has caused severe electricity shortages in the country.

The “Peace” pipeline originates from the South Pars gas field in Iran’s southern city of Asalouyeh. It is to pass through Bandar Abbas and Iranshahr, in Iran’s Sistan-Baluchistan province, until it reaches Khuzdar, in Pakistan’s Baluchistan province. From Khuzdar, the pipeline would continue through Sui to Multan with one extension going to Karachi.

The part of the project that is on the Iranian side is close to completion. Since Pakistan lacks the funds to start building the pipeline on its territory, Iran has offered to provide 500 million dollars, one third of the required amount, to start the project, beginning later this month.

The Barack Obama administration has warned Pakistan “to avoid any sanctionable activity” even while recognising Pakistan’s growing needs for more energy resources.

Pakistan’s media has supported the gas pipeline with Iran and questioned the benefit of the strategic alliance between the U.S. and Pakistan.

Other media accused the U.S. of a double standard in its foreign policy for “threatening Pakistan with sanctions for its ties with Iran, while Russia, China and India have very close economic and political ties with Iran.”

Both Pakistan and Iran face the challenge of ethnic and sectarian unrest. Unlike in Iraq and Afghanistan, Iran has not played that card with Pakistan. This could relate to the fact that Pakistan could retaliate by actively supporting the Jundollah militant group in Sistan-Baluschistan province, one of Iran’s most sensitive and volatile regions.

Iran has criticised “the shortcomings” of Pakistani government forces for failing to prevent Baluch militants from attacking Iran, but the Tehran government has avoided confronting the Pakistan government over this issue.

The Iran-Pakistan relationship goes beyond the Peace Pipeline and it is more vital for Iran than for Pakistan. Pakistan has helped Iran develop its nuclear programme and Iran may be considering Pakistan a potential ally in the case of confrontation with the United States or Israel.

Iran’s policy towards Pakistan is an example of how economic priorities supersede ideology. However, it remains to be seen if projects such as the Peace Pipeline will be the start of strategic alliance between the two large Muslim countries.

Such an alliance would have major impact on the geopolitics of the region and could be critically important in the aftermath of international forces’ departure from Afghanistan.

Photo Credit: AFP 

Print Friendly


About the Author

avatar

Articles by guest writers.



One Response to For Iran and Pakistan, Energy Trumps Enmity

Show Comments →



  1. avatar ed says:

    The Administration has repeatedly cajoled and threatened Pakistan to discourage it from developing an IP pipeline in concert with Iran, and it has done so in several ways- e.g., by providing some limited help on hydropower projects, including the Tarbela dam, to alleviate Pakistan’s energy shortage, and by stoking unrest and terror in Balochistan with the ultimate objective of creating an independent state under U.S. control. This would enable it to prevent the Chinese from developing the port at Gwadar or later accessing it as a docking site and energy hub. It would also give the U.S. control over a critical link and hub of its long planned TAPI pipeline, as well as strategically located real estate vis a vis Iran and Afghanistan.

    Moreover, by continuing to apply sanctions on Iran and impeding its natural gas trade with its neighbors, it would make the development of the Pars natural gas fields under the present regime that much more problematic and expensive.

    All of this is well and good, except that there is the small matter of international law and the sovereignty of nations.

    In contrast, improved relations with Pakistan and the IP pipeline would help stabilize the region, including create an opportunity for better relations between Pakistan and India if a further link to India were to be built, as was originally intended. What the Administration has seemed to discount is that the peaceful business opportunities for trade and investment for U.S. companies in the region would be enormous if it were to abandon its obsession with maintaining an imperial military presence in the region, or containing and forcing regime change in Iran. Smart, effective and nuanced diplomacy would yield more certain results than our present approach, and at much less cost. Unfortunately, that would require a different paradigm and policy, and that is something the Administration has seemed unwilling to explore.

Back to Top ↑
  • Categories


  • Subscribe to LobeLog

    Enter your email address to subscribe to our site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Popular Posts