LobeLog on Facebook LobeLog on Facebook

Analysis donald-erdogan-kapak-880

Published on November 23rd, 2016 | by Derek Davison

3

Erdogan: Democracy Respecter?

by Derek Davison

Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the president of Turkey, had some harsh words on Wednesday for Americans who are criticizing their new president-elect, Donald Trump:

“The West will continue to welcome tyrants who have blood on their hands with red carpets and label anyone who criticizes them as a dictator,” said Erdogan who is frequently criticized for his increasingly autocratic style of governing.

“Are they calling someone a dictator? Then you should think the opposite. That person is good, because (he or she) goes against their interests,” Erdogan said…

In the televised speech, Erdogan said anti-Trump protesters in Western nations had no respect for democracy or the result of the U.S. election.

“In America they started calling Trump a dictator. In various countries of Europe they spilled into the streets and started saying ‘dictator,'” said Erdogan. “I thought you were democrats? Why aren’t you respecting the results of the ballot box?”

If anyone can speak to the importance of respecting democracy, it is Erdogan, whose own respect for democracy knows no bounds:

The President of Turkey has said democracy and freedom have “absolutely no value” in the country after calling for journalists, lawyers and politicians to be prosecuted as terrorists.

Recep Tayyip Erdogan spoke on Wednesday as almost 50 people, including activists and academics, were detained in a wave of police raids.

In a speech to local politicians in Ankara, he criticised critics raising concern over Turkey’s record on “democracy, freedom and rule of law” as discussions over a landmark deal on the refugee crisis continue.

Erdogan understands that there can be no respect for democracy unless the defeated side in a democratic election is able to accept the results of that election peacefully and in good faith:

The first is relations between the government led by the Justice and Development party (AKP) and Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and its political and societal affiliate, the Union of Communities in Kurdistan (KCK). A war between these two sides has been going on since Turkey’s June 7, 2015 parliamentary election. The war accelerated when President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and the AKP were unhappy with the election results, in which they did not receive enough votes to seek a referendum to move Turkey’s political system from a parliamentary to a presidential system. One of the strategies of Erdogan and the AKP was to appeal even more strongly to ultra-Turkish nationalists to achieve this goal. Full-scale war commenced in July and has been ongoing since.

For example, a true democracy respecter must respect the fact that his or her political opponents will win elections from time to time and must not try to subvert or overturn those outcomes:

The two joint leaders of Turkey’s pro-Kurdish Peoples’ Democratic party (HDP) have been detained along with at least 10 MPs because of their reluctance to give testimony for crimes linked to “terrorist propaganda”.

Police raided the Ankara home of co-leader Selahattin Demirta? and the house of co-leader Figen Yüksekda? in Diyarbak?r, the largest city in Turkey’s mainly Kurdish south-east, early on Friday.

It goes without saying that someone who respects democracy must also respect the things that make democracy possible, like a free and adversarial press:

Erdogan’s increasingly dictatorial style of governance claimed another victim. On March 4, supported by a ruling from Erdogan’s courts, Turkish authorities forcibly seized the offices of Zaman, Turkey’s largest daily newspaper, and then attacked those protesting the seizure with tear gas. Zaman had ties with Gulen’s Hizmet movement and was often critical of Erdogan and the AKP—it has now been reopened as a thoroughly pro-government outlet. It is hard to see the Zaman seizure as anything other than the final end of any semblance of press freedom in Turkey, the act of a government that will no longer tolerate dissent.

Indeed, a broad climate of free and open speech must be respected:

Overnight, educators became a suspected class. The Education Ministry dismissed more than 27,000 staff and Turkey’s Council of Higher Education forced all 1,577 university deans to resign, saying only those with no ties to coup plotters would be reinstated. The university watchdog also ordered each university to list faculty suspected of links to Mr. Gulen and has suspended 4,225 academics. The 15 Gulen-linked universities have been sealed like crime scenes.

So far, the purge has affected mainly academics on the outs with Mr. Erdogan even before the coup attempt, chiefly those connected to Mr. Gulen and to causes seen as critical of the government. But the chill is broadening, and many academics from top schools, expecting a second wave of purges, are seeking work abroad.

Additionally, one should respect the separation of powers so as not to consolidate too much authority in the hands of one person:

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan cited Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler to defend his controversial push to expand the powers of the presidency, local media reported on Friday.

Erdogan, the strongman of Turkish politics for more than a decade, is seeking a new constitution to transform his post into a powerful US-style executive “super-presidency,” which he says will provide more effective governance.

“In a unitary system (such as Turkey’s) a presidential system can work perfectly,” Erdogan was quoted as telling reporters in Istanbul on Thursday on his return from a visit to Saudi Arabia.

“There are already examples in the world and in history. You can see it when you look at Hitler’s Germany,” he was quoted as saying.

Fortunately for Americans who may find their respect for democracy wavering, there is a true democracy respecter in Ankara, governing a NATO ally no less, to whose shining example they might turn in this turbulent post-election period. Democracy itself owes him a debt of gratitude.


About the Author

avatar

Derek Davison is a Washington-based researcher and writer on international affairs and American politics. He has Master's degrees in Middle East Studies from the University of Chicago, where he specialized in Iranian history and policy, and in Public Policy and Management from Carnegie Mellon University, where he studied American foreign policy and Russian/Cold War history. He previously worked in the Persian Gulf for The RAND Corporation.



3 Responses to Erdogan: Democracy Respecter?

Show Comments →



  1. avatar ARK says:

    If politic was about playing on human sentiments to gain power for ulterior motives, then Erdogan of Turkey is playing them well, using the three R factors, namely, Race, Religion and Resources. With Race, he has mesmerized and duped the West, by holding the portray of Kemal Ataturk, who inspired Hitler and Mussolini, and the white supremacists of today. With Religion, He has managed to create the Islamic Army of Conquest, promising the Arabs and the Turkic Jihadists to conquer Europe and create the Caliphate of the Western Hemisphere. With Resources, He is promising the West free flow of Qatar Natural Gas, and the oil-flow to the Mediterranean Sea flowing from South (Arabia) to the North (Turkey) through the ISIL controlled, Sunni lands in Iraq & Syria. All this while he is mobilizing 20 to 30 million Islamic Jihadists from the Central Asia to eliminate the Kurds and force a regime change in Syria, and possibly Iran and Iraq, to clear the way for the Turkistan Islamic Army to march toward the West.
    PLEASE WAKE UP PEOPLE AND OBOLISH THE COUNTRY OF TURKEY. YOU WILL THEN HAVE ELIMINATED THE RACISM OF ATATURK, AND THE THREAT OF THE ISLAMIC JIHAIDST OF TURKISTAN. MAY THEN PEACE PREVAL IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND BEYOND..

  2. avatar ARK says:

    If politic was about playing on human sentiments to gain power for ulterior motives, then Erdogan of Turkey is playing them all, using the three R factors, namely, Race, Religion and Resources. With Race, he has mesmerized and duped the West, by holding the portrait of Kemal Ataturk, who inspired Hitler and Mussolini, and the white supremacists of today. With Religion, he has managed to create the Islamic Army of Conquest, promising the Arabs and the Turkic Jihadists to conquer Europe and create the Caliphate of the Western Hemisphere. With Resources, he is promising the West free flow of Qatar Natural Gas, and the oil-flow to the Mediterranean Sea flowing from South (Arabia) to the North (Turkey) through the ISIL controlled, Sunni lands in Iraq & Syria. All this while he is mobilizing 20 to 30 million Islamic Jihadists from the Central Asia to eliminate the Kurds and force a regime change in Syria, and possibly Iran and Iraq, to clear the way for the Turkistan Islamic Army to march toward the West.
    Please wake up people and abolish the country of Turkey. You will then have eliminated the racism of Ataturk and the threat of the Islamic Jihadists of Turkistan. May then, peace prevail in the Middle East and beyond…..

  3. avatar Deborah says:

    Looks like a flagrant case of Erdogan-Flynn quid pro quo to me: Michael Flynn’s Consulting Firm May Have Violated Federal Lobbying Law”, Chuck Ross, Daily Caller, 11/24/2016

All comments are moderated. Comments with links will not be published. Read our Comment Policy page for further information.

Back to Top ↑
  • Categories


  • Subscribe to LobeLog

    Enter your email address to subscribe to our site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Popular Posts